Review: Journeying with Grace Nichols
Arts
45 views
45 views

Review: Journeying with Grace Nichols

Kate Dennett - October 12, 2018
University of Sussex Joins Libraries Week
Arts
88 views
88 views

University of Sussex Joins Libraries Week

Kate Dennett - October 6, 2018
Oscar Jerome at The Hope and Ruin
Interview
77 views
77 views

Oscar Jerome at The Hope and Ruin

Alex Leissle - October 4, 2018
Why we should all embrace drag
Lifestyle
107 views
107 views

Why we should all embrace drag

Chris Ahjem - October 3, 2018
In Conversation with Alannah Myles
Arts
141 views
141 views

In Conversation with Alannah Myles

Anastasia Konstantinidou - October 3, 2018
Brighton Needs You!
News
108 views
108 views

Brighton Needs You!

Anonymous - September 28, 2018
Books Every Fresher Should Read
Arts
244 views
244 views

Books Every Fresher Should Read

Anonymous - September 19, 2018
France in Fine Fettle
Sports
186 views
186 views

France in Fine Fettle

Anonymous - September 17, 2018
Dive into Brightonian Culture
Arts
199 views
199 views

Dive into Brightonian Culture

Anonymous - September 17, 2018
Oh, baby, baby, did you see Britney at Pride?
Arts
228 views
228 views

Oh, baby, baby, did you see Britney at Pride?

Anastasia Konstantinidou - September 15, 2018
Joe Armon-Jones Brings Jazz to Patterns
Music
32 views
32 views

Joe Armon-Jones Brings Jazz to Patterns

Lara Antoine - October 13, 2018
738 Views
13 Comments

Double standards and legitimate criticism

Should there be freedom to criticise religion or does doing so automatically make it racism? Good question. Most of us are aware that people are sensitive to religious criticism to the extent that they will call it racism, and sometimes justifiably so. And it’s definitely fair to say that sometimes the line between criticism of a religion and ‘racism’ is easily crossed.

There is a problem however, with the statements and suggestions made by writer of the article ‘Freedom to criticise, or racism?’ who also wrote an article titled ‘To answer your question: I would say freedom fighters‘ which ultimately praised Hamas.

There is a part of this article which states that anti-Zionism is not anti-Semitism, and that a clear distinction must be made between the two; a statement which the majority of people would agree with. That criticism or rejection of a political view must be made separately from the religion from which it might claim to represent or take root in.

Why then, is it acceptable for the writer to be so insistent on making clear the separation of religion and politics in that particular instance, but claim in another article that criticism of politics that involve people who happen to be Muslim is suddenly unacceptable?

The article ‘Freedom to criticise, or racism?’ claimed that the attempt to ban Azzam Tamimi from speaking at Sussex and an article in The Badger which criticised Hamas were both overt and covert attacks on the Muslim members of our community. I have to say that this claim is nothing short of ridiculous.

Both of these incidents were legitimate criticisms of Hamas (and Azzam Tamimi is a supporter of Hamas) who are essentially an anti-Semitic, homophobic and an internationally condemned political terrorist group. It was not criticising Islam as a religion. When did it become ‘racist’ to condemn people or groups who carry out or condone suicide bombings, as both Hamas and Azzam Tamimi have done?

The claim of these incidents being part of a ‘campaign against Muslim members of our community’ is fundamentally both incorrect and expresses extreme double standards for different religions. It cannot be one rule for Islam and its political offshoots and another for anyone else. These people are not criticised for their religion, but their political actions.

There is a still fundamental problem with the title of the article ‘Freedom to criticise, or racism?’ as well as with what I have just written. Both suggest that there should be no room to criticise religion, when of course there must be. Even those that believe in religion must be open to criticism for it. It is impossible to fully accept something that you have not questioned and heard opposition to. There is nothing in this world that is perfect and without its problems.

It has to be acknowledged that the main content of the article in question presented us with the basic fact that there has been a rise over the past few years in Islamaphobia. There is no denying that. Similarly, I am all too aware of how criticism of a religion or its politics can lead to ‘racism’ (and this is all based on the largely debatable assumption that it is possible to classify a religion as a race).

Yes, the distinction needs to be made between those who put forward legitimate criticism and those who should be deemed as ‘racists’.

The ones we should be truly deeming as ‘racists’ are people that reject the fundamental rights of others to hold a certain religious belief or maintain an ethnic background; people whose aim it is to prevent religious practices, people who conduct physical attacks on others simply because of the religion, race or nation they belong to, people who vandalise places of worship or religious monuments, people who make derogatory or slanderous remarks towards a race, a religion or the people practicing it, and people who have a rejection to any religious or ethnic groups basic right to self determination.

Though the writer also acknowledges these things as racism in his article, it would appear that he also has an ironic inability to apply his own standard of separation universally.

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam
Review: Journeying with Grace Nichols
Arts
45 views
45 views

Review: Journeying with Grace Nichols

Kate Dennett - October 12, 2018
University of Sussex Joins Libraries Week
Arts
88 views
88 views

University of Sussex Joins Libraries Week

Kate Dennett - October 6, 2018
Oscar Jerome at The Hope and Ruin
Interview
77 views
77 views

Oscar Jerome at The Hope and Ruin

Alex Leissle - October 4, 2018
Why we should all embrace drag
Lifestyle
107 views
107 views

Why we should all embrace drag

Chris Ahjem - October 3, 2018
In Conversation with Alannah Myles
Arts
141 views
141 views

In Conversation with Alannah Myles

Anastasia Konstantinidou - October 3, 2018
Brighton Needs You!
News
108 views
108 views

Brighton Needs You!

Anonymous - September 28, 2018
Books Every Fresher Should Read
Arts
244 views
244 views

Books Every Fresher Should Read

Anonymous - September 19, 2018
France in Fine Fettle
Sports
186 views
186 views

France in Fine Fettle

Anonymous - September 17, 2018
Dive into Brightonian Culture
Arts
199 views
199 views

Dive into Brightonian Culture

Anonymous - September 17, 2018
Oh, baby, baby, did you see Britney at Pride?
Arts
228 views
228 views

Oh, baby, baby, did you see Britney at Pride?

Anastasia Konstantinidou - September 15, 2018
Joe Armon-Jones Brings Jazz to Patterns
Music
32 views
32 views

Joe Armon-Jones Brings Jazz to Patterns

Lara Antoine - October 13, 2018

13 Comments

  1. It is very interesting to accuse me of double standards. Now lets see, who is it that tried to ban a speaker from coming to campus? How come you fail to mention that you and the society you represent tried to prevent someone from expressing themselves on campus? Especially after the speaker’s performance made it absolutely clear that any accusation of anti-semitism directed against him was unfounded (or maybe you chose not to attend the meeting in question so as not to be convinced).
    Once more, what is racist is to present a picture of Islam as a religion which is inherently violent and whose followers are all terrorists. This is because as you rightly point out in your article, there has been a rise in islamophobia in recent years, and it is the product of the war on terror. This is what I was attacking and all that goes with it, i.e the constant whipping up of hysteria concerning resistance organisations such as Hamas and Hezbollah.
    Finally, about Hamas. Needless to ask for a direct response to my article because there will be none, so strong are the arguments presented there that it is difficult to counter them. But at least be informed about what you allege. Hamas the political organisation is not considered terrorist in Britain, only its military wing. And even if we count the countries where Hamas or its military wing are considered terrorist, this boils down to a handful of Western states who all have a stake one way or another in the war on terror. So the allegation about Hamas being an ‘internationally condemned terrorist group’ is a load of nonsense.
    Criticise Hamas and Tamimi as much as you want. But dont try to ban them from our platforms on the grounds that they are fascist (remember that was the Union policy in line with which you tried to ban them). That correlates rather oddly with passionate pleas about ‘freedom of criticism’.

    Reply
  2. Fair enough I suppose, but the article which was criticised appeared to fail to condemn Geert Wilder, who is a racist.

    Reply
  3. Wilder has said that he is not racist, but this is a fairly transparent claim in my opinion and his bald ‘I’m not racist’ statement, coupled with a ludicrous propaganda campaign, has unfortunately been fairly successful in getting his flatulent, punchable face on television.

    I think that the author of the ‘freedom for criticism’ article is either partially sighted or didn’t bother to watch the film properly if he’s been prepared to essentially display a fence-sitting attitude to this politician.

    Reply
  4. “Now lets see, who is it that tried to ban a speaker from coming to campus? How come you fail to mention that you and the society you represent tried to prevent someone from expressing themselves on campus”
    I don’t mention it because it’s irrelevant who it was. Just to clarify, does that mean that you were against the No Platform policy and would be quite happy to hear members of the BNP come on to campus? To me, that policy is there in part to protect the students at this university, and to protect any group of people who genuinely feel threatened by the speaker or what they represent. I count Hamas and anyone that supports them as people i’d feel threatened by when they clearly are an anti-Semitic group. Just one example of this being a Hamas leader in January saying that Jewish children all around the world are now legitimate targets. Anyone that stands up as Tamimi does and shouts “We are all Hamas” does not make him someone that should be welcomed with open arms on to campus.

    Reply
  5. “a political philosophy, movement, or regime (as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual… severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition” – Merriam-Webster

    Fits the bill quite appropriately…

    Reply
  6. Comment stolen from another thread: “It is true that there is a rise in anti-semitism. This has to be countered. But have you asked yourself why this rise in anti-semitism? Why every time Israel commits acts of atrocity more and more people turn against t Jews? Israel kills and destroys and justifies this in the name of Judaism. It seems to me then that the best way to fight anti-semitism is to fight Israel itself for this is not what Judaism is about.”

    and hence why the Union should have reacted. A pro-hamas speaker is not a bad thing, but a pro-hamas speaker in the immediate wake of Iraeli / Arab conflict is a sure fire recipe for populist movement.

    Anti-Semitism and Anti-Zionism are separate issues sure, but seeing as criticising Hamas apparently is an attack on Islam, then an attack on Israeli politics (at least taking Christakis’s line) should be considered anti-semitism – otherwise you’ve the double standards issue.

    Reply
  7. I’ve read a few of these articles and their associated comments, and it seems to me that the majority of the argument here is simple semantics – everyone seems to be using their own definiton of racism to condem each other as racist, which is obviously going to provoke a reaction as that’s a dirty word nowadays.

    Reply
  8. Judith,
    The No Platform policy, which I entirely endorse, is directed against fascists such as the BNP (and incidentally, similar organisations such as Wilders’s one). Unless you try to prove that Tamimi is a fascist, trying to ban him from speaking makes you using double standards. You cant interpret union policies in the way you want when that suits your interests (remember you argued against a No Platform policy). To anyone who has been to Tamimi’s meeting, it was entirely obvious that the man is not anti-semitic and that the message he was putting forward was anti-Zionist, not anti-semitic. If you persist in arguing the two to be the same, that’s your problem, not anyone else’s.
    Paul, I see the last point you make in your comment. But the problem is that it reproduces the Zionist claim that Zionism represents the Jews. It doesn’t. It is the political philosophy which underpins the existence of the State of Israel and as such it is distinct from Judaism. Attacking Israel, and hence Zionism, is in no way an act of anti-semitism, that’s why so many Jews attack Israel (politically I mean, not physically). It is not the same as my claim that calling Hamas terrorist and whipping up hysteria around it is Islamophobic. You have to take into account the context. You have a region mainly populated by Muslims under constant attack from the Western powers and its allies (especially Israel). When these people try to resist (by espousing various political philosophies, the most important one today being Islamism), we call them terrorist. Doing that serves the interests of the warmongers and denies the people of the region the legitimacy to resist. That’s why it has to be fought.
    Chris Postle, I use the term racism to mean a discrimination against a group of people united by race, religion or nationality, i.e very broadly. That’s why I also use the term ‘islamophobia’ to speak about the specific form of racism directed against Muslims. It is a dirty word, but unfortunatel the only way to clean up the mess is by rolling back the influence of racism. That’s what I am trying to do.

    Reply
  9. Christakis,
    Firstly, i most certainly have never argued against a No Platform policy, so i’m not sure where you’re getting that claim from. Secondly, any group is well within their rights to use it when they see fit, i.e. when they feel under threat. It was more than clear that this was the case by the amount of people that turned up to the council meeting. The No Platform policy is there to protect students, not just students that belong to a religious or ethnic group. If people are facing any possibility of physical threat because of what they believe in, then that threat should be removed.
    Anyone that supports and encourages attacks on other innocent people because of their political belief – or i’d go as far as to say their nationality, as the talk condoned attacks on Israelis in Israel- (as Tamimi does and he repeated this in his talk) has no place on campus.
    I’m going to say this one more time. You have written:
    “Attacking Israel, and hence Zionism, is in no way an act of anti-semitism, that’s why so many Jews attack Israel (politically I mean, not physically). It is not the same as my claim that calling Hamas terrorist and whipping up hysteria around it is Islamophobic.”
    – Replace the word ‘Israel’ with ‘Hamas’, or any other condemned political group that makes any kind of claim in the name of a religion, and replace the word ‘Jews’ with ‘Muslims’ and ‘Zionism’ with ‘Islamism’ , and you end up arguing an entirely different point. That’s what i mean about double standards. Hamas are terrorists. It is not hysteria. Claiming that saying this is Islamaphobic is just not true.

    Reply
  10. As a Jewish student at Sussex, I would like to state that I did attend Tamimi ‘s speech on campus in January and he was not anti-semitic in ANY way. If he was, I, and I’m sure many others, would have challenged him on this. Anti-Zionism is a separate issue.

    In the words of the late Harold Pinter and others in a public letter last April:

    “We cannot celebrate the birthday of a state founded on terrorism, massacres and the dispossession of another people from their land. We cannot celebrate the birthday of a state that even now engages in ethnic cleansing, that violates international law, that is inflicting a monstrous collective punishment on the civilian population of Gaza and that continues to deny to Palestinians their human rights and national aspirations.

    We will celebrate when Arab and Jew live as equals in a peaceful Middle East. “

    Reply
  11. Dr Tamimi is not just anti-zionist, he’s anti-Israeli. All Israelis. I base this on his defending of the act of suicide bombing and claims that he would commit a suicide bombing. Saying that you would murder a random sample of a population of a country suggests that you have no regard for the humanity of that population.

    Reply
  12. 33injection,

    I’m not sure why you feel that by stating your religious beliefs as some kind of disclaimer to your comment it makes any difference to what you’ve just said.
    If you were an Israeli or Zionist sitting in that audience being described as a cancer that must be eradicated from humanity or hearing a man say that the only reason he hadn’t blown himself up somewhere where you have friends and family was because he wasn’t allowed in the country, are you really telling me you’d feel quite safe and not at all threatened?
    I am not going to enter into a debate on the middle east over this article because that was not what I was aiming to do, so your Harold Pinter quote is irrelevant to both the article and the thread.
    I am saying that criticising Azzam Tamimi and saying that should not have been allowed to speak on campus was not racist or Islamaphobic.
    If speaking out against and criticising someone’s politics means that you’re a racist, then apply that to everything- which you clearly aren’t going to do, because if you argue so strongly that anti-Zionism is not anti-Semitism, you have to also argue that criticism of Tamimi, Hamas or any other political group or leader is not Islamaphobic. That’s it.

    Reply
  13. It’s pathetic and cheap to use the old ‘racism’ card when discussing something that isn’t about race.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Join the Badger Team

Apply today!

Latest Posts

Review: Journeying with Grace Nichols
Arts
45 views
Arts
45 views

Review: Journeying with Grace Nichols

Kate Dennett - October 12, 2018

In celebration of Black History Month, Sussex Student Union organised a number of interesting talks and events across October. One of these exciting opportunities was a chance…

Review: Suzanne Ciani & Martin Messier at the ACCA
Film & Theatre
47 views
Film & Theatre
47 views

Review: Suzanne Ciani & Martin Messier at the ACCA

Anonymous - October 10, 2018

At the outset, Mr Messier’s FIELD at once invoked The Matrix and Daedalus’ Boiler Room set.  The basic concept of this mixed media performance relies on transducer…

Shelf Help: The Organisation Encouraging Self-Development
Arts
72 views
Arts
72 views

Shelf Help: The Organisation Encouraging Self-Development

Kate Dennett - October 10, 2018

To commemorate to this year’s Mental Health Awareness Day, I found it increasingly difficult to draw attention to just one book of relevance in recognition of this…

Freshers’ Week from a second year perspective
Campus News
69 views
Campus News
69 views

Freshers’ Week from a second year perspective

Chris Ahjem - October 9, 2018

Annually, the University of Sussex welcomes thousands of new students to our Falmer campus and every year the Student’s Union and Brighton based clubs and businesses increase…

National Badger Day: 10 fun facts you might not have known
News
105 views
News
105 views

National Badger Day: 10 fun facts you might not have known

Chris Ahjem - October 6, 2018

To celebrate National Badger Day here are 10 fun facts about our animal kingdom namesake Badgers can run up to 16-19 miles per hour which is the…

University of Sussex Joins Libraries Week
Arts
88 views
Arts
88 views

University of Sussex Joins Libraries Week

Kate Dennett - October 6, 2018

This coming week marks the celebration of Libraries Week, an event solely dedicated to praising the work of libraries across the UK. This annual event is taking…

Oscar Jerome at The Hope and Ruin
Interview
77 views
Interview
77 views

Oscar Jerome at The Hope and Ruin

Alex Leissle - October 4, 2018

The young star is often a tricky title to navigate. There are the big names, who explode into the world with noise, bright light, a big record…

How Fenty Beauty changed the face of the makeup industry
Lifestyle
104 views
Lifestyle
104 views

How Fenty Beauty changed the face of the makeup industry

Rachel Badham - October 3, 2018

Fenty Beauty, launched in September last year, is a makeup line created by global superstar Robyn Rihanna Fenty, better known as Rihanna. It’s not uncommon for celebrity…

Why we should all embrace drag
Lifestyle
107 views
Lifestyle
107 views

Why we should all embrace drag

Chris Ahjem - October 3, 2018

Once an art form disregarded by many, 2018 bears witness to the continuous rise of drag as a legitimate, celebrated art. Spearheaded by RuPaul’s Drag Race, drag…

In Conversation with Alannah Myles
Arts
141 views
Arts
141 views

In Conversation with Alannah Myles

Anastasia Konstantinidou - October 3, 2018

This week we had the pleasure of interviewing Alannah Myles, the 1991 Grammy winner for best female rock vocal performance for her outstanding vocal abilities for the…

Brighton Needs You!
News
108 views
News
108 views

Brighton Needs You!

Anonymous - September 28, 2018

Brighton is a vibrant and thriving city that many students at Sussex are lucky enough to call home. But there are many in the area in need…

Books Every Fresher Should Read
Arts
244 views
Arts
244 views

Books Every Fresher Should Read

Anonymous - September 19, 2018

Starting university comes with both exciting but potentially daunting changes, with both moving away from home and studying at degree level posing to be two new challenges.…

INCREDIBLES 2: The Sequel with a Feminist Twist
Film & Theatre
178 views
Film & Theatre
178 views

INCREDIBLES 2: The Sequel with a Feminist Twist

Olek Młyński - September 18, 2018

One key film in the development of anyone who grew up in the early 2000s was The Incredibles (2004). It’s comedy, vibrancy, and general sense of fun…

France in Fine Fettle
Sports
186 views
Sports
186 views

France in Fine Fettle

Anonymous - September 17, 2018

Prior to the start of the quadrennial tournament this summer, football fans across the world grew sceptical over Russia’s credentials and ability to host the most prestigious…

Dive into Brightonian Culture
Arts
199 views
Arts
199 views

Dive into Brightonian Culture

Anonymous - September 17, 2018

Boredom is impossible when you throw yourself into everything this weird and wonderful city has to offer. The specific and unique cultural wonders of Brighton are indeed…

Oh, baby, baby, did you see Britney at Pride?
Arts
228 views
Arts
228 views

Oh, baby, baby, did you see Britney at Pride?

Anastasia Konstantinidou - September 15, 2018

During this year’s Pride Festival, Brighton had the honour of welcoming international pop star and voice of the early 2000s, Britney Spears, to the main stage. Undoubtedly,…

Union obliterates the debate – unwritten requirement used to shut down free speech debate
Campus News
1288 views1
Campus News
1288 views1

Union obliterates the debate – unwritten requirement used to shut down free speech debate

Jordan Wright - April 27, 2018

Student society Liberate the Debate’s most recent event was cancelled over a lack of compliance with the Students' Union's (USSU) requirement for a neutral chair - a…

Joe Armon-Jones Brings Jazz to Patterns
Music
32 views
Music
32 views

Joe Armon-Jones Brings Jazz to Patterns

Lara Antoine - October 13, 2018

Photo by Vojta Dvrocek Whether you’ve seen him in Ezra Collective or featuring alongside other breakthrough neo-jazz artists like Mr Jukes. Pianist Joe Armon-Jones is no stranger…

“Climax” review – The return of the French provocateur
Arts
44 views
Arts
44 views

“Climax” review – The return of the French provocateur

Olek Młyński - October 11, 2018

The newest film from the notorious Gaspar Noé was so critically acclaimed at the Cannes Film Festival that the director himself could not believe it. Climax opens…

Kode9 & Burial – Fabriclive 100
Music
88 views
Music
88 views

Kode9 & Burial – Fabriclive 100

Ryan Bridgewater - October 5, 2018

Released 28th September Available on: CD/Vinyl/Download   The anticipation couldn’t have been greater when the final instalment in London nightclub Fabric’s legendary DJ mix series was announced…

News
66 views

Maniac: a madcap adventure into troubled minds

Olek Młyński - October 5, 2018

With the release of Maniac, Netflix once again proves itself as an artistic powerhouse. This mini-series is a whirlwind of creativity containing often confusing, madcap ideas. But,…

Nike cash in on Kaepernick campaign
Sports
67 views
Sports
67 views

Nike cash in on Kaepernick campaign

James Cohen - October 4, 2018

In 1988 Nike premiered their, now infamous, “Just Do It” campaign, showing 80-year-old Walt Stack jogging across the Golden Gate Bridge. 30 years and a lot of…

Machine Learning for an Efficient Future
Science
103 views
Science
103 views

Machine Learning for an Efficient Future

ecrm20 - October 4, 2018

My project is about how we can explain the predictions made by machine learning algorithms. For example, if we have an algorithm that tells us whether an…

Sticky Mike’s Frog Bar Due to Close
Music
116 views
Music
116 views

Sticky Mike’s Frog Bar Due to Close

Dan Miller - October 4, 2018

[caption id="attachment_35890" align="alignnone" width="4544"] Photo by Lara Antoine[/caption]   The surprising news was released via the venue’s Facebook page on Tuesday afternoon, announcing:    "There are far too many…

Where did you Come from Where did you Escargot?  Martlets Snailway appears in Brighton and Hove
News
98 views
News
98 views

Where did you Come from Where did you Escargot? Martlets Snailway appears in Brighton and Hove

Jessica Hubbard - October 3, 2018

Colourful Snail statues have appeared across Brighton and Hove. The Snails are part of an art trail turned fundraising initiative by Martlets, a hospice and charity. Fifteen of…

In conversation with Novympia at The Glitter Ball
Interview
107 views
Interview
107 views

In conversation with Novympia at The Glitter Ball

Chris Ahjem - October 3, 2018

Towards the start of The Glitter Ball, I managed to chat with Nova and Olympia (with interruptions from Charmaine Diamond White) about what drag means to them,…

Interview
59 views

In conversation with Alfie Ordinary and Baby at The Glitter Ball

Chris Ahjem - October 3, 2018

During the course of the night, I managed to sit down with Alfie and Baby to interview them about their start in drag, how LGBTQ+ students should…

In conversation with DragSoc’s committee members at The Glitter Ball
Interview
72 views
Interview
72 views

In conversation with DragSoc’s committee members at The Glitter Ball

Chris Ahjem - October 3, 2018

I was lucky enough to be given the chance to watch DragSoc’s amazing Glitter Ball and then interview the performers in the packed Activities Office staff room…