9 Views

A premature neonate has a 50% chance of survival. What will you do?

Hannah Faith Leigh

 

Option A: to continue treatment in the form of intensive care; the child may survive but with severe deformities.
Option B: Switch to palliative care and withdraw/withhold treatment.
Which would you choose? It’s pretty difficult to imagine in this scenario what you would do. In a society where one could argue our moral compass is open to interpretation, perhaps this sort of decision has no clear immediate answer. So which option is lawful? And who is it that sets the guidelines for making these decisions?
The answer to this kind of dilemma, or at least a discussion of similar scenarios, was what we expected from a lecture on Ethical Dilemmas In Healthcare on Wednesday 14thNovember. Presented by Hugh Whittall, Director of the Nuffield Council on Bioethics (introduced as Hugh Nutall, but not by any means nutty) the lecture was part biography, part theory, and offered very little in the way of answers.
‘FYI’ quipped our lecturer, by way of introduction, and rattled off his CV.  Mr. Whittall worked at the Department of Health on human fertilization and embryology with emphasis on the ethics surrounding IVF in its earlier days. He then joined the European Commission in Brussels to encourage the formation of a multi-disciplinary team of medics, scientists and philosophers who would make policy decisions about how to handle ethical issues in healthcare. This ‘crowd’ comprised a number of Cambridge geneticists and philosophers, whose prime directive was to distinguish the ‘etymology from the metaphysics in bioethics‘. In the style of Hugh Whittall: “LOL”.
So what are these ‘ethical dilemmas’ that face our society and keep people in the Nuffield Council on Bioethics in a job? Genetic testing: should there be disclosure in families about the existence of a hereditary disease? Should there be a DNA database? Should we introduce electronic tagging for dementia sufferers? How about the use of restraints? Is it right to lie to someone with dementia who continues to ask for his wife who has been dead for 5 years? These along with lifestyle issues such as obesity, the emergence of new technologies and telemedicine (the remote monitoring of compliance with medication) were some of the examples we, the audience, were made aware of.
The quips continued as Hugh guided us through the world of transparency and trust, public awareness and interest. He contrasted the cost of a book on The Ethics of Banking at £139 with Trust Me I’m a Junior Doctor at one penny, and the public outrage at fouling in football juxtaposed with the reaction to the withdrawal of penicillin for black men, in the treatment of Chlamydia, in the south of the USA, during the 1970s.
The Nuffield Council on Bioethics is an independent body, which produces reports on ethical issues within biology and medicine. The impact of these reports was made clear when Mr. Whittall described the council’s intervention on the forensic use of biological information and the police DNA database. The Council suggested that keeping DNA on file irrespective of charge was an unwarranted intrusion. As a result the European Court of Human Rights forced the UK to change its policy.
The reports produced by the Council set a framework for responding to different situations, which of course differ on a case-by-case basis. Guides to these reports are usually 20 pages long, and if any of you reading this are in doubt as to Mr Whitall’s independence from government, you will be reassured that these are made into a one-page format for MPs.
With regard to public health, the council suggests that the role of the state be based on stewardship and an ‘intervention ladder’, for instance, in cases of: infection, obesity and smoking, the level of involvement should be evidenced. This can range from doing nothing (bottom of the ladder) to legal prohibition and war (top of the ladder), where the latter requires a great deal of justification and evidence.
To answer the title of this article, the guidelines from Nuffield on the withholding or withdrawal of treatment vs. living with a disability can be found in the report on Critical Care Decisions in Foetal and Neonatal Medicine (2006). However, in short, if decisions are made consensually by the parents and doctors, and are in the best interests of the baby, they are considered lawful.

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam

Leave a Reply

Join the Badger Team

Apply today!

Latest Posts

The Russian State Ballet of Siberia’s Cinderella review
Arts, Film & Theatre
16 views
Arts, Film & Theatre
16 views

The Russian State Ballet of Siberia’s Cinderella review

Georgia Grace - February 23, 2018

The Russian State Ballet of Siberia came to the Theatre Royal Brighton this week with a trio of classic ballet performances to impress a range of audiences.…

Billionaire builds colossal 10,000 year clock
Science, Science & Technology
30 views
Science, Science & Technology
30 views

Billionaire builds colossal 10,000 year clock

Luke Richards - February 23, 2018

Amazon founder Jeff Bezos has gone ahead with a plan to build a giant clock to promote long term thinking. The clock's design should allow it to…

Neuroscience: it must be love on the brain
Science, Science & Technology
77 views
Science, Science & Technology
77 views

Neuroscience: it must be love on the brain

Luke Richards - February 23, 2018

If you're madly in love, I'd like to ask you to take a moment to consider what exactly is happening inside your brain. Love is a many-chemical…

Rockets and technopoltics: SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy
Science, Science & Technology
48 views
Science, Science & Technology
48 views

Rockets and technopoltics: SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy

Luke Richards - February 23, 2018

The launch of SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy could become a defining feature in humanity's exploration of space, but this impressive technical feat opens up a new frontier of…

Should the monarchy be abolished?
News
23 views
News
23 views

Should the monarchy be abolished?

Will Cronk - February 23, 2018

YES William Cronk Since the time of Alfred the Great, this country has had a monarch of some form or another. The monarchy has provided stability and…

News, Podcast
28 views

News Round Up: UCU strike updates, tuition fees and more

William Singh - February 23, 2018

In this news round up of the week, Will and Deniz catch you up on everything going on around campus. Thanks for listening and tune in next…

Academic Armchair- iObjectify: self- and other-objectification on Grindr
Features, Top Stories
22 views
Features, Top Stories
22 views

Academic Armchair- iObjectify: self- and other-objectification on Grindr

Devin Thomas - February 23, 2018

The Badger Features Team interviewed Sussex’s Yasin Koc about his work on the psychological factors behind Grindr. He posits that use of the app is associated with…

The Badger Reviews: Derry Girls
Arts, Film & Theatre
25 views
Arts, Film & Theatre
25 views

The Badger Reviews: Derry Girls

Sophie Coppenhall - February 22, 2018

[embedyt] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-MwnpSEzprQ[/embedyt] This week, Sophie our film editor, reviews season one of Derry Girls. Have you seen it? What did you think? Leave us a comment on…

Arts, Film & Theatre
40 views

Krater’s Valentine’s Day Special review

Daniel Green - February 21, 2018

Love was in the air at a Valentine’s special of Krater Comedy Club last Wednesday and, despite the pouring rain outside, Komedia was packed full of people…

‘Paws for Pensions’ among strike event schedule
Campus News, News
41 views
Campus News, News
41 views

‘Paws for Pensions’ among strike event schedule

William Singh - February 21, 2018

University of Sussex staff are hosting a full slate of events on strike days, including talks, teach-ins, and even a day to bring along your puppers. Members…

Exploring Mumbai Street Food
Lifestyle
40 views
Lifestyle
40 views

Exploring Mumbai Street Food

Louisa Streeting - February 21, 2018

Mumbai is a place that assaults the senses; an array of smells you’ve never smelt before, vibrant colours, and constant noises from the surge of tourists and…

Comment, Opinion
44 views

Comment Cast: Misogyny In Hollywood

Will Cronk - February 21, 2018

In the is episode, Will and Sophie discuss misogyny in film and tv. For more, pick up a badger around campus or read it online. Tune in…

Students need to support the UCU strike
Comment, Opinion
51 views
Comment, Opinion
51 views

Students need to support the UCU strike

Johnbosco Nwogbo - February 20, 2018

The question of whether or not the current UCU strike is justified is an easily settled one, if one took a broad view. According to the Joseph…

Women’s suffrage 100 years on: what’s changed?
Features, Top Stories
49 views
Features, Top Stories
49 views

Women’s suffrage 100 years on: what’s changed?

Roisin McCormack - February 20, 2018

As it reaches a century since the defining moments of women’s suffrage, Roisin McCormack looks into how much things have really changed. Is a celebration of the…

Retrospective: Paul Thomas Anderson’s ‘Punch Drunk Love’ (2002)
Arts, Film & Theatre
31 views
Arts, Film & Theatre
31 views

Retrospective: Paul Thomas Anderson’s ‘Punch Drunk Love’ (2002)

Gabriel Ross - February 20, 2018

During a 2002 interview with Charlie Rose, when asked whether he is going to take some time off, Adam Sandler promptly replies, “I don’t really wanna have…

News
52 views

Live: Students’ Union decides on UCU strike backing

William Singh - February 19, 2018

U.S.S.U-Turn: 54 students decide stance for 17,000
Campus News, News
68 views
Campus News, News
68 views

U.S.S.U-Turn: 54 students decide stance for 17,000

Jordan Wright - February 19, 2018

On Monday 19th February, the Students’ Union Council will vote on whether or not to support the national Univerity  and College Union (UCU) strike action that is…

The Wombats: ‘Beautiful People Will Ruin Your Life’ review
Arts, Music
38 views
Arts, Music
38 views

The Wombats: ‘Beautiful People Will Ruin Your Life’ review

Matthew Nicholls - February 19, 2018

Three years after their last release, The Wombats are back with their long awaited fourth album ‘Beautiful People Will Ruin Your Life’. Since 'Glitterbug' reached number 5…

Artist Focus: Ella Barkhouse
Artist Focus, Arts
50 views
Artist Focus, Arts
50 views

Artist Focus: Ella Barkhouse

Louisa Hunt - February 19, 2018

Ella Barkhouse is a second-year Brighton student, studying Fine Art: Critical Practice course. Her work ranges across all sorts of media, from some more traditional writing, drawing…

The ultimate LGBTQ+ books guide this February
Books
76 views
Books
76 views

The ultimate LGBTQ+ books guide this February

Shiri Reuben - February 19, 2018

  Throughout the month of February, LGBT History Month aims to promote tolerance and spread awareness of the historical and present-day prejudices faced by lesbian, gay, bisexual…